CO129-171 - Acting Governor Austin - 1875 [7-11] -- Sir Kennedy - 1875 [12] — Page 473

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

469

and Mr Austin Coates openly said that he expected to become a valuable interpreter,

which I understand generally to mean that they intend to give him rank & prospects in the service equivalent to those who have entered after competitive examinations in England.

A. Kennedy's views

I am no absolute believer in competitive examinations, but I do think it has great practical merits. Apart from the question of who is likely to exercise patronage best, the competition system in England appears to me to bring the Govt. to where there is a larger supply of the article required, & then to exclude by a harmless process.

The very wording of this despatch appears to me to show that they have rather made a place for a man, than found a man for a place; & I think the 1st answer should certainly be that no evidence as to both necessity for creating this new appointment should be shown.

As to the general question, you have before you, it. of abandoning the system of cadets, increasing the number of inferior clerkships with a view to attracting a better class of officers. I confess I altogether differ from Sir ...

The individual in question here has apparently qualifications which remove him from the two first of these categories, but I should surmise he was not up to the mark in the 3rd.

I believe it to be very desirable that the heads of departments in Crown Colonies should have had a good general education, as well as official training; and it is in the former respect that I believe Sir ...

Edit History

2026-05-21 05:10:10 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
469 and Mr Austin Coates openly said that he expected to become a valuable interpreter, which I understand generally to mean that they intend to give him rank & prospects in the service equivalent to those who have entered after competitive examinations in England. A. Kennedy's views I am no absolute believer in competitive examinations, but I do think it has great practical merits. Apart from the question of who is likely to exercise patronage best, the competition system in England appears to me to bring the Govt. to where there is a larger supply of the article required, & then to exclude by a harmless process. The very wording of this despatch appears to me to show that they have rather made a place for a man, than found a man for a place; & I think the 1st answer should certainly be that no evidence as to both necessity for creating this new appointment should be shown. As to the general question, you have before you, it. of abandoning the system of cadets, increasing the number of inferior clerkships with a view to attracting a better class of officers. I confess I altogether differ from Sir ... The individual in question here has apparently qualifications which remove him from the two first of these categories, but I should surmise he was not up to the mark in the 3rd. I believe it to be very desirable that the heads of departments in Crown Colonies should have had a good general education, as well as official training; and it is in the former respect that I believe Sir ...
Baseline (Original)
469 and Mr Austin sage openly that he in lapected to become valuable interpreter which I understand generally to incan that they intend to five him rank & prospects in the service Equivalent to those who have sutured after competitive examinationis in England. A A. Kennedy's views Jam no absence believer in Competitive Exan inctions, but I do think it has preat practical merits. Apart from the question of who is likely, to exercise patimage best, the competition Segaton in bagland appears to me bring the Govt from to where there is a larger supply of mall masker- the article required, & then to exclude than by a < hamless process (1) this very idle (3* the venz The very wording of this despatch appers to me to shew that they have rather made a place for a man, found man for a place; & Ithink the 12 answer should certainly be that mon evidence as both necessity for Creating this new appointment should be Shewr which Ebelieve As to the general questio, You have before you, it. of abandering System of cadets, timcreasing the Bay of inferin clerkships with a view to attracting a lot of intermediate class of officers I confess I altogether differ from Sis stupid (2) the very imperfectly coluncated__ The individual in prestion here has apparently has qualifications which remove him from the two first of there Categories, but Ishould surmise he was bit ups to the mark in the 3rd, Ibelieve it to be very the 3rd respect injour tout to Set- for the heads of departeients in Crown Colonier hier of ford general education having had as well as official training; and it is in the former respect that I belive sit
2026-05-21 05:10:10 · Baseline
View content

469

and Mr Austin sage openly that he in

lapected to become

valuable interpreter

which I understand generally to incan that they intend to five him rank & prospects in the service Equivalent to those who have

sutured after competitive examinationis in England.

A

A. Kennedy's views

Jam no absence believer in

Competitive Exan inctions, but I do think it has preat practical merits. Apart from the question of who is likely, to exercise patimage best, the competition Segaton in bagland appears to me bring the Govt from

to where there is a larger supply of

mall masker-

the article required, & then to exclude

than

by a

< hamless process (1)

this

very

idle

(3*

the

venz

The very wording of this despatch appers to me to shew that they have rather made a place for a man, found

man for a place; & Ithink the 12 answer should certainly be that mon evidence as both necessity for

Creating this new appointment should be Shewr

which

Ebelieve

As to the general questio, You have before you, it. of abandering

System of cadets, timcreasing the Bay of inferin clerkships with a view to attracting

a lot of intermediate class of officers I confess I altogether differ from Sis

stupid (2) the very

imperfectly coluncated__

The individual in prestion here has apparently has qualifications which remove him from the two first of there Categories, but Ishould surmise he was bit ups to the mark in the 3rd,

Ibelieve it to be

very

the 3rd respect

injour tout to Set- for the heads of departeients

in Crown Colonier hier of ford general education

having had

as well as official training; and it is in the former respect that I belive sit

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.